At the beginning of Paramount Pictures new Movie ‘Annihilation’ we witness a meteor streaking through the atmosphere to wind up crashing into a small lighthouse. A little while later we learn that the lighthouse has become the center of an unearthly ‘shimmer’ that is slowly growing and that anyone who enters the shimmer never returns.
After several failed expeditions a team of five women enter the shimmer to discover that the plants and animals are all mutating. It was at this point, not quite halfway into the film that I said to myself: ‘this is the Colour out of Space by H. P. Lovecraft’. Actually ‘Annihilation’ would have been better if it had just stuck to being an update of Lovecraft’s story.
For those who haven’t read Lovecraft, in the ‘Colour out of Space’ a meteor lands on a New England farm and a strange unearthly colour (Lovecraft was thinking of something like Ultraviolet or Infrared light but somehow alive) begins to spread. The colour proceeds to suck the life out of every living thing on the farm.
O’k so in ‘Annihilation’ the meteor lands in a lighthouse instead of a farm, it generates a shimmer rather than a colour and causes mutations instead of sucking the lifeforce but those are just details. It’s really the same story plot.
The only part of ‘Annihilation’ that is different is an idea that gets mentioned along the way that anyone who volunteers for a suicide mission must have something terribly wrong with their life. The main character Lena, played by Natalie Portman certainly does. Her husband joined an earlier mission into the shimmer because he found out she was having an affair and now she feels guilty about him so she volunteers for the next mission. Much too much of the movie is taken up with this pointless subplot.
Oh, I know. Nowadays when you tell a story you simply have to have well-developed characters that your readers or viewers can care about. You can take it from me however, there’s no one in this movie to care about. Also you can add the fact that the ‘surprise ending’ simply wasn’t.
Now Annihilation wasn’t all bad, the special effects were good and the basic idea of something really alien coming to our world on a meteor is intriguing. In fact it is revealed later in the movie that the shimmer isn’t causing mutations so much as mixing the DNA of different creatures.
Then when Lena finally reaches the lighthouse we see things like glass trees along the beach. Since glass is made out of sand I started to wonder if the shimmer is now mixing life and non-life! That would have been cool but nothing is done with the concept!
Really, eliminating the trite infidelity subplot and putting a lot more thought into the Science Fiction elements would have made Annihilation a much better film. As it is we never learn anything about why this ‘Shimmer’ came to Earth or where it came from or what it is trying to do.
Annihilation is based on a novel of the same name by Jeff VanderMeer (who also wrote the screenplay with director Alex Garland) and is the first part of a trilogy. Maybe in the other novels we get some of the answers but frankly I don’t know if I’m interested. I think I’ll reread ‘The Colour out of Space’ instead.
First – What Is Annihilation? The concept of Annihilation within the book and also within the movie is a materially important concept to understand. The first most obvious definition of annihilation is that of the destruction of the earth as it becomes something different and new. The annihilation of Kane as he becomes Kane1.
Thanks for the comment. I agree that the entity represents change through mixing and in some respects it’s only our fear of change that makes annihilation a monster. However, that still doesn’t justify the pointless subplot or the in-fighting among the explorers. Again, more attention to the SF elements, such as the glass trees on the beach, would have made for a better story in my opinion. And if you want a better story read Lovecraft’s “The Colour out of Space”!
Bob L
Thank you, I like how you show examples to us.
Thank you. I’m glad you like my site and I hope you’ll recommend it to your friends.
Bob L
Hi there, just became alert to your blog through Google,
and found that it is really informative. I’m going to watch out for brussels.
I will be grateful if you continue this in future.
Numerous people will be benefited from your writing.
Cheers!
Thanks for the comment and come back soon!
Bob L
Hey! I could have sworn I’ve been to this site before but after checking through some of the post
I realized it’s new to me. Anyhow, I’m definitely happy
I found it and I’ll be book-marking and checking back frequently!
Thanks for the comment and come back soon!
Bob L
I have to admit I loved the Annihilation book and film. It has aspects of Lovecrafts the colour out of space and John Carpenters the Thing body horror. I think it deals more with existential matters against the backdrop of Sci fi. Grief is a big thing, one of the women lost a child, cancer too is dealt with one of the women is dying and the mutations in the shimmer reflect that, also guilt and depression are reflected in the other two women.It has a lot going on. That’s why I love it, it’s intelligent sci fi and an update and loving homage to the master of cosmic horror H.P Lovevraft.
Thanks for the comment. Was ‘Annihilation’ meant to be an homage to Lovecraft? I agree it was intended as serious SF, which I will never argue against, but I still think there was too much emotional baggage. Still I appreciate your viewpoint, I just think it could have been a lot better. Thanks again!
Bob L
Howdy are using WordPress for your site platform? I’m new to the blog world but I’m
trying to get started and create my own. Do you need any html coding expertise to make your
own blog? Any help would be greatly appreciated!
Thanks for the comment. I do use wordpress as my platform, no coding required. I got it from my blog host ipage. Hope that helps and good luck!
Bob L