Month: March 2022

Geologists are making new discoveries that reveal the inner structure and workings of our planet Earth.     

Back about fifty years ago now the science of Geology underwent a revolution in thought as overwhelming evidence supporting the theory of ‘Plate Tectonics’ was uncovered. The basic idea of plate tectonics is that the surface of the globe is broken into a number of plates that the continents sit upon. Those plates move, extremely slowly, only centimeters per year but they do move and as they move they jostle and crash against one another causing earthquakes to occur, mountains ranges and volcanoes to be born.

The major Tectonic Plates of the Earth. Where these plates meet are the geologically active regions of the world with earthquakes, volcanoes and mountain building. (Credit: Wikipedia)

Sometimes one plate is forced under another, and when that happens a ‘subduction zone’ is created and one of the geologic features that can occur in such a zone is a deep-water trench such as the Marianas Trench, the deepest place in all of the oceans. The Marianas Trench is in fact only one of about a dozen trenches that are a part of the famous ‘Ring of Fire’ surrounding the Pacific Ocean. The precise mechanics of how these subduction zones are generated is very complicated, several attempts have been made to develop numerical models for analyzing them with computers.

Deeper than Mount Everest is high the Marianas Trench in only one of a dozen trenches that ring the Pacific Plate. (Credit: Youngzine)
The three ways that Tectonic Plates can interface. Subduction zones occur at convergent plate boundaries. (Credit: Science Sparks)

Now a new such model developed at the Instituto Dom Luiz at the University of Lisbon in Portugal has shown great promise in providing a more comprehensive and accurate picture of subduction zone evolution. This new simulation is different from previous models in that it is a full scale three-dimensional reproduction of what is going on at a subduction zone. In the program all of the dynamic forces that effect the generation and evolution of subduction zones were realistically incorporated, including gravity.

While Plate Tectonics gives us a general idea of what is going on at a Subduction Zone we need a much more detailed analysis if we hope to predict such events as earthquakes and volcanoes. (Credit: Volcano Discovery)

Such large scale simulations can require a lot of computer time; in fact each analysis using this new model takes as much as a full week to process using the supercomputer at Johannes Gutenberg University in Germany. Still the results are well worth the effort. According to Jaime Almeida, first author on the study. “Subduction zones are one of the main features of our planet and the main driver of plate tectonics and the global dynamics of the planet.”

Modern Supercomputers are performing calculations so large that they can even model events with millions of variables with constantly changing parameters. (Credit: The Atlantic)

Plate Tectonics has taught us much about the broad outline of how the surface of our Earth has changed over billions of years. However a more precise and accurate model of the processes involved may help us better understand, and therefore predict the disasters like earthquakes and volcanoes that are a common threat around the world.

Millions of people live next door to volcanoes and unexpected eruptions are major disasters. The ability to better predict such eruptions is a major goal of geology. (Credit: The Atlantic)

Now I’d like to take a moment to update a geology story that I posted about back on the 24th of June 2020 and 10th of April 2021. The story concerned the discovery of two huge, massive blobs that exist deep within the Earth’s mantel. These blobs are formally known as Large Low-Shear Velocity Provinces (LLSVPs) and differ in composition and viscosity from the surrounding material deep within the Earth. (Previously these blobs were known as Ultra Low Velocity Zones or ULVZs). The LLSVPs were detected because; being made of different materials the vibrations caused by earthquakes travel through them at a lower velocity, hence Low-Shear Velocity. They were discovered by analyzing the data from hundreds of earthquakes as measured by seismographs from around the world.

There are two big blobs of material buried deep beneath the surface of the Earth. Known as Large Low Shear Velocity Zones they are one of the big mysteries in the science of Geology. (Credit: ScienceDirect.com)

The two LLSVPs are situated one beneath South Africa and the other beneath the Pacific Ocean and are each the size of a continent with a thickness of greater than 500 km. Also, it has been speculated that the blobs may in fact be the remnants of an ancient planet called Theia that collided with the Earth four and a half billion years ago fragments of which then became our Moon.

About four and a half billion years ago a planet the size of Mars collided with the early Earth. Named Theia some of that planet’s material went on to become our moon. The possibility that the LLSVZs may be fragments of Theia has been suggested, and would be really cool! (Credit: Wikipedia)

Now a new analysis of the LLSVPs by Qian Yuan and Mingming Li of Arizona State University’s School of Earth and Space Exploration has been published in the journal Nature Science. In the article the researchers assert that the LLSVP under Africa is almost 1000 km further from the center of the Earth, and therefore closer to the surface than the one under the Pacific. In an attempt to explain this difference in height the researchers hypothesize that the Africa LLSVP could be less dense and therefore it may be ever so slowly rising through the Earth’s mantel. “The Africa LLSVP may have been rising in recent geological time,” states author Li. “This may explain the elevating surface topography and intense volcanism in eastern Africa.”

Geologists probe the interior of our planet by studying the vibration caused by earthquakes. Primary (P) waves can pass through the liquid core at Earth’s center while the Secondary (S) cannot. The LLSVZs were discovered by a careful analysis of those P and S waves. (Credit:

It is harder to study what goes on just a few hundred kilometers beneath our feet than it is to study the surface of the Moon or Mars, certainly we’ve sent more probes to the Moon or Mars than we have to a hundred kilometers down. Nevertheless bit by bit geologists are learning the secrets of the planet we all call home.

Astronomy News for March 2022: How do Supermassive Black Holes form? News observations of a pair of Supermassive Black Holes may tell us a great deal about their origin.     

Twenty years ago the idea that some of the largest galaxies possessed a ‘Supermassive Black Hole’ in their center was a major discovery. Since that time more and more evidence has accumulated that every galaxy, even many small ones, possess such black holes whose mass can be anywhere from tens of millions to billions of times that of our Sun. One of the major questions in astronomy today is whether supermassive black holes came first and formed galaxies around them or does the formation of galaxies lead to the creation of supermassive black holes. By the way, this is a question that it is hoped the new James Webb Space Telescope may provide some evidence to help answer.

Once known as Quasars, now referred to as Active Galactic Nuclei (AGN) Supermassive Black Holes that are feeding on the material around them are the most energetic objects in the Universe. (Credit: Space.com)

One thing we do know is that big galaxies form by combining smaller galaxies, or more often by a big galaxy gobbling up a small one. Our own Milky Way is now known to have gobbled up as many as a half dozen smaller galaxies over the last billion years or so. So what happened to the supermassive black holes in those now consumed galaxies, are they wandering around somewhere in our galaxy or did they become absorbed by the Milky Way’s supermassive black hole.

There are currently many competing models of galaxy formation. Here’s one. (Credit: ResearchGate)

Probably both. If the two galaxies strike each other in a glancing blow the black holes at their centers may never come within tens of thousands of light years of each other and may wander around separately for billions of years. On the other hand astronomers think that sometimes the black holes can become entangled and will then begin to orbit each other. If that occurs the two supermassive black holes will start to emit gravity waves so that slowly the energy of their orbit will radiate away causing them to move closer and closer until they merge.

The LIGO and Virgo Gravity Wave Observatories have now observed dozens of stellar sized black hole mergers. A merger between two supermassive black holes will be a real event! (Credit: The Indian Express)

Evidence for the latter scenario has recently been uncovered and published in the Astrophysical Journal Letters. The evidence comes from a black hole situated in a galaxy about 9 billion light years away, which you will remember means that the events we are watching actually took place 9 billion years ago. The supermassive black hole, which has been designated as PKS 2131-021, is devouring a considerable amount of matter. A small amount of that matter is escaping from the black hole in the form of a high energy jet. Such objects are called Blazars and it so happens that PKS 2131-021’s jet is pointing right at Earth giving us an excellent look at what is going on.

The Supermassive Black Hole designated as PKS 2131-021 is actually two massive black holes orbiting each other. The gravity waves given off by the black holes is causing them to come closer together until, some day they will merge. (Credit: Live Science)

And recent observations have shown that the energy from PKS 2131-021 fluctuates on a regular basis, around every two years the intensity dips slightly only to soon recover. Checking data going back 45 years from five observatories the researchers confirmed their own observations.

Some of the data obtained from PKS 2131-021, the two black holes are pretty obvious. (Credit: CatTech)

The astronomers hypothesize that the cause of the variation could be another supermassive black hole in a tight orbit around PKS 2131-021, the tightest known orbit for a pair of supermassive black holes. Using Einstein’s Theory of Gravity the astronomers have calculated that the two black holes should merge in about 10,000 years or so and when they do they will produce massive amounts of gravity waves that will the shake the fabric of space-time throughout the observable Universe.

To Newton Space and Time were separate, fixed, unalterable. To Einstein both space and time are connected and a lot more flexible. (Credit: Forber)

In previous posts, 7 October 2017, 22 October 2017 and 23 September 2020, I have talked about the LIGO and Virgo laser gravity wave observatories and how over the last ten years they have succeeded in capturing the final outbursts from mergers of several pairs of stellar mass black holes, black holes with masses 5-10 times that of our Sun. So far however they haven’t observed gravity waves from pairs of Supermassive black holes, such events are very rare even in the entire Universe. Perhaps with a few more upgrades however they might be able to start picking up the gravity waves already coming from PKS 2131-021.

LIGO consists of two gravity wave interferometers. This one in Washington state and another identical one in Louisiana. (Credit: LIGO CalTech)

Astronomers will continue to study PKS 2131-021, with both gravity wave observatories and more old fashion telescopes hoping to learn more of its secrets. The more astronomers observe the Universe the more common Supermassive Black Holes have become so that it’s a good question. Does the Universe consist of Galaxies of stars with Supermassive Black Holes at their hearts, or does it consist of Supermassive Black Holes with a halo of stars around them?

Archaeology News for March 2022     

Even while the Covid-19 pandemic continues to rage around the world scientists have been reexamining the pandemics of the past in their efforts to uncover something useful for their fight against Covid. In these posts I have already mentioned the ‘Spanish Flu’ pandemic of 1919-1920 and its similarity to Covid-19.

Even during the ‘Spanish Flu’ pamdemic of a hundred years ago there were people too stupid to put on their masks. (Credit: Wikipedia)

Now a team of researchers at the Max Planck Institute for the Science of Human History has published a new study in the journal Nature Ecology and Evolution of arguably the best known plague of all time, the ‘Black Death’ of the mid 14th century. Caused by the bacteria Yersinia pestis the bubonic plague is considered to have been responsible for the death of as much as 50% of the population of Europe between the years 1347 to 1352.

Bring out your dead was no joke during the middle of the 14th century as bubonic plague took the life of as much as half the people in Europe. (Credit: Critical Specator)

Like all of our knowledge of history, what we know about the Black Death comes from those people who kept the records of that time, the literate people who lived in the towns or monasteries. Those records tell us much about the heavy toll the plague took on the people who lived in those communities. Unfortunately those records tell us very little about what was happening to the country people, the peasants, who made up more than 75% of the population in Europe back then.

Yersinia pestis, the bacteria that causes the black death. It may look harmless but ever today in some parts of the world it takes its toll. (Credit: CDC)
Much of our knowledge of the Middle Ages comes from the writings of the few people who could read and write, and most of them were monks in monasteries. (Credit: by Sterling Lynch)

In order to correct for this urban basis in our knowledge of the effect of the Black Death the team from Max Planck used a new archaeological technique called Palynology, which is the study of fossil plant spores and pollen. The rational for the study was this, if the death rate due to the plague among the rural population was a high as it was in the cities and towns, about 50%, then large areas of once cultivated land should have reverted to wilderness in the years after 1352. Such a large scale change in the flora would be reflected in the kind of pollen that was deposited into the ground from that time.

The size shape and ‘spikiness’ of pollen grains varies so greatly that it makes it possible for experts to identify the species of plant that the pollen comes from. (Credit: Wikipedia)
 

The researchers collected pollen samples from over 1,600 sites spread throughout Europe and analyzed them. What they found was that the mortality caused by the plague varied widely from location to location, with some rural areas like those in Germany and Italy being hit just as hard as nearby cities while other localities suffered far less. Ireland, for example showed hardly any change at all.

Rational behind the pollen study to the mortality caused by the black death. Areas of Europe that had high mortality would see a change in the variety of vegetation, and hence fossil pollen, while areas that were unaffected would see little change in the pollen. (Credit: The Conversation)

These results correlate well with what epidemiologists are seeing today. Covid-19 may be a worldwide pandemic but how it effects each and every human being depends very much on local conditions where they live.

While Covid-19 has spread worldwide its effects haven’t been equally as deadly everywhere. Some nations have been badly hit while others only slightly. (Credit: ResearchGate)

On a lighter note another team of archaeologists with the Max Plank Institute for the Science of Human History have unearthed an Old Stone Age site not 160 kilometers from present day Beijing in China. The site, which is in the Nihewan Basin to the northwest of the Chinese capital and has been given the name Xiamabei, was carbon dated to between 39,000 and 41,000 years ago and consists of a layer of remains that had been buried about 2.5 meters beneath the surface. During their excavations the archaeologists found and removed 380 small stone tools and artifacts along with 430 mammal bones.

The site was also identifiable by several artifacts that had been stained red by the mineral ochre, which is known to have been used by many primitive cultures as a dye because of its resemblance to the colour of blood. The Xiamabei site is the oldest ochre culture site to have been found in the Far East but the pigment is known to have been used in Europe and Africa as long ago as 300,000 years.

Archaeologists excavating the Nihewan Old Stone Age site west of Beijing. (Credit: SciTechDaily)
 
The use of red Ochre as a pigment has been attested in many Stone Age cultures throughout the Old World. (Credit: ResearchGate)

 According to co-author Shixia Yang, a scientist with the Chinese Academy of Sciences, “The remains seemed to be in their original spots after the site was abandoned by the residents. Based on this, we can reveal a vivid picture of how people lived 40,000 years ago in eastern Asia.”

The use of red Ochre as a pigment has been attested in many Stone Age cultures throughout the Old World. (Credit: ResearchGate)
 

One big question left unanswered by the investigation so far is exactly what kind of human beings lived at the Xiamabei local. 40,000 years ago the residents could have been modern Homo sapiens but they could also have been either Neanderthals or Denisovans, the lack of any human bones makes it impossible to be certain. However a slightly younger, nearby location called Tianyuandong, lying about 110 kilometers away, has had remains of H sapiens identified there so the likelihood is that the Xiamabei site was made by our direct ancestors.

What’s the difference between Neanderthals and Modern Humans, not really all that much! (Credit: Quora)

Just another couple of stories about the science of archaeology uncovering small bits of our past.

For Billions of Years Bacteria have been recycling the waste produced by other creatures. Now Scientists have developed a genetically modified strain of Bacteria that can convert Carbon Dioxide into useful chemicals.      

If human civilization is to survive on this planet we must learn how to recycle the industrial chemicals that make modern society. That’s all there is to it. We cannot continue to produce plastics and them just throw them away without them clogging our rivers and oceans. We cannot go on manufacturing Chlorofluorocarbons (CFCs) without them leaking out and destroying the ozone layer. And most of all we cannot persist in burning fossil fuels and just releasing CO2 into the atmosphere without catastrophic effects on our climate.

Every day in every way we’re just turning more and more of our planet into a Trash Dump! (Credit: JSTOR Daily)

It shouldn’t be too hard to accomplish. After all nature somehow managed to recycle the chemicals of life over and over again for billions of years without waste products accumulating and becoming a problem. Life here on Earth had evolved into a well tuned machine that took energy from the Sun and used it to cycle carbon through many different creatures. Much of that recycling was done by some of the simplest creatures, bacteria, who took the waste products, or corpses of larger living things and broke down the complex chemicals of ‘higher life forms’ so that they could be used again and again. Perhaps then, it might be a good idea for us to if possible find or otherwise develop strains of bacteria that can consume some of our waste products and convert them into substances that are not harmful, or perhaps even useful.

Over millions of years Mother Nature has developed countless Food Chains or Food Webs that succeed in endlessly cycling carbon without producing any harmful pollution. (Credit: YouTube)
Very few species of bacteria actually cause disease. Most live by consuming dead plant and animal material and turning it back into fertilizer that plants can absorb as nutrients. (Credit: Microbiology Society)

That is exactly what researchers at Northwestern University and the firm LanzaTech are doing. What the scientists have done is to select and modify a strain of bacteria in order to enable them to absorb CO2 and convert it into the useful chemicals acetone and isopropanol (IPA).

A leader in the field of waste recycling LanzaTech is developing new strains of bacteria to use in fermenting waste material that otherwise would just become pollution. (Credit: Polyestertime)

Both Acetone and IPA are industrial chemicals that are manufactured in large quantities from petroleum in processes that emit significant amounts of CO2. Acetone is a well known solvent for both plastics and synthetic fibers as well as being the most commonly used nail polish remover. On the other hand IPA is the main ingredient in many disinfectants including two that are recommended by the World Health Organization for their ability to kill the SARS-CoV-2 virus. Together these two compounds have a yearly sales market of over $10 billion. Techniques that could manufacture these chemicals in an environmentally friendly way would be a major step forward in developing a sustainable economy.

In addition to many industrial uses Acetone is best known as the main ingredient in nail polish remover! (Credit: Martha Stewart)

And new gas fermentation process that produces Acetone and IPA developed by Northwestern actually removes CO2 from the atmosphere helping to reduce the green house gasses already put there by power station and gas burning vehicles. Starting with an anaerobic (Non-oxygen breathing) bacterium called Clostridium autoethanogenum the researchers at LanzaTech succeeded in reprogramming the bacterium to ferment CO2 out of the air and convert it to IPA and acetone. As related by study co-author Michael Jewett, “By harnessing our capacity to partner with biology to make what is needed, on a sustainable and renewable basis, we can begin to take advantage of the available CO2 to transform the bioeconomy.”

Judging by this facility outside Chicago LanzaTech is making considerable progress in its goal to remove CO2 from the air and turn it into useful products. (Credit: The Business Journals)

Just another example of how building a sustainable society doesn’t have to mean going back to the Middle Ages. We can protect our planet, and all of the creatures on it if we just use our brains and are willing to try new techniques for manufacturing those products that a modern society requires. Bioengineering can help us to develop a bioeconomy, an economy that can work with the Earth instead of poisoning it.

The technology of the Middle Ages simply cannot support the number of people living on our planet today so we just cannot go back. Instead we must use our technology to solve our problems rather than simply hoping that if we ignore them they’ll go away. (Credit: Pinterest)

Paleontology News for March 2022: Several New Species that Illustrate the Diversity of Life throughout Earth’s Past.     

If you think about it, the most impressive thing about life here on Earth is its enormous variety. Looking at some of the more unusual species of life around the world makes you wonder just what limits there are to the kind of creature evolution can come up with. Consider the nudibranch and the millipede, the flying squirrel and the flying snake or how ’bout just the duck billed platypus all by itself!

No legs (Nudibranch Left) and many legs (Millipede right) evolution has tried it all! (Credit: Ikelite / ResearchGate)
Flying Squirrel (l) and Flying Snake (r), again how does evolution manage to accomplish the same task in so many different ways? (Credit: Lewisboro Field Guide / New York Post)

It’s hardly surprising therefore that in the long history of life there should be many creatures that are even stranger. As I usually do I’ll begin my discussion of new unusual fossils in the distant past and work my way forward in time.  

Considered to be the top predator of its days Anomalocaris was a strange shrimp indeed! (Credit: Wired)

Many of the strangest creatures ever found have come from the Burgess Shale fossil site in British Columbia. Even the names of some of the species discovered there indicate how strange they are. Anomalocaris (literally strange shrimp) and Halluciogenia (literally a hallucination) are two of the best known but over the last several decades both of these animals have had several related species uncovered in other fossil sites so that the taxonomy of these ‘weird wonders’ is now better understood.

Hallucinogena is another of the wield wonders of the Burgess Shale but like Anomalocaris paleontologists have found other, similar creatures so that they are no longer quite so unique. (Credit: National Geographic)

Not so Opabinia, a five-eyed creature with a backward facing mouth, segmented body with flaps instead of legs and a long elephant-like nose. Although Opabinia had been first described by Walcott in 1912 as an unusual arthropod it was only in 1975 when paleontologist Harry Whittington dissected specimens of the creature using techniques he himself had developed that Opabinia was recognized as the bizarre creature we now know. And in the years since then Opabinia remained a unique creature with no known relatives.

Over the last fifty years however Opabinia has remained unique, no related species of any kind, until now. (Credit: Simple Wikipedia)

Until now, for a reinterpretation of a fossil from the 500 million year old middle Cambrian Wheeler Formation in Utah by lead author Steven Pates of Harvard’s Department of Organismic and Evolutionary Biology has found another member of Opabinia’s family. The fossil has been named Utaurora comosa and was first described in 2008 as a relative of Anomalocaris.

Despite its proboscis being broken off otherwise Utaurora comosa is quite similar to Opabinia. (Credit: Wikipedia)

While U comosa does possess some similarities to Anomalocaris the re-evaluation by the team at Harvard clearly shows that the species bears a striking resemblance to Opabinia. Unfortunately the anterior nose of U comosa has broken off making an exact comparison to Opabinia’s nose impossible. However there does appear to be enough left to assert that the proboscis of U comosa seems to be smaller. At the same time the tail flaps of U comosa appear slightly different, more fan like.

Looks like a great place to go fossil hunting the Wheeler Formation in Utah is famous for its Cambrian Trilobites! (Credit: Utah Geological Survey – Utah.gov)

The Wheeler Formation is several million years younger than the Burgess shale so perhaps U comosa is a slightly evolved descendant of Opabinia. In any case Opabina is no longer unique, it has a relative and as more such relatives are found the family’s position in the tree of life will become clearer.

Moving about 50 million years into the future the dominant creature of the Silurian seas were giant sea scorpions, formally known as eurypterids. Ancestors to both modern scorpions and spiders, sea scorpions were predators like their descendants and some species grew to over a meter in length making them among the largest of all arthropods.

In some cases as large as a man the Eurypterids were the top predators during the Silurian period. Related to modern scorpions they certainly look quite nasty. (Credit: The Irish Times)

Now a new species of eurypterid has been identified in Australia that is the largest specimen discovered in the land down under. The fossil itself had been unearthed years ago and left stored in the Queensland Museum in Australia but only recently has it been thoroughly examined. Realizing that the fossil was that of an eurypterid the creature is estimated to have been as much as a meter in length and has been given the formal name of Woodwardopterus freemanorum.

The Fossilized head of Woodwardopterus freemanorum was lying unexamined in a museum drawer for decades before someone realized just what it was. (Credit: Phys.org)
Artists impression of what W freemanorum looked like. (Credit: List23)

Of course even the largest creatures of the Cambrian and Silurian periods were small compared to the later dinosaurs. And the largest, best known predator from the age of the dinosaurs was the famous Tyrannosaurus rex or just T rex. One thing about the T rex that sooner or later everybody finds curious are the two tiny, seemingly useless arms that the giant meat eater possessed. Did those petite appendages have any use at all or were they vestigial organs, like our own appendix, useless but not yet eliminated by evolution.

Ever since it was first discovered paleontologists have wonder what, if anything T rex did with those tiny arms! (Credit: DW)

Now a new species of large predatory dinosaur has been discovered in the Los Blanquitos Formation in the Amblayo region in the north of Argentina whose arms are comparatively even shorter than T rex’s. Named Guemesia ochoai by its discoverers from the Natural History Museum in London the animal belongs to a family of dinosaurs called the abelisaur who were distantly related to the Tyrannosaurs that roamed North America at approximately the same time.

A South American relative of T rex Guemesia ochoai possessed even smaller, and presumably less useful arms. (Credit: Phys.org)

As a group abelisaurs were 5 to 10 meters in length and used their powerful heads and jaws to seize and kill their victims. The researchers who described G ochoai were not exactly certain of the creature’s size because the specimen they unearthed could have been a Juvenal. The major difference between the abelisaurs and the northern Tyrannosaurs was that the southern theropods had shorter, deeper skulls that often bore crests or bumps on it.

The major difference between the southern abelisaurs and T rex and its relative appears to be a shorter face and bumps on the skull. (Credit: Blogtuan.info)

 Regardless of the actual adult size of G ochoai that fact that large, predatory dinosaurs on two continents both evolved arms that were so small as to be practically useless tells us a lot about the way they attacked their prey. If you think about it however, in our modern world wolves take down their prey without using their forelegs, it’s all just teeth and jaws.

For great white Sharks it’s all about teeth and jaws. Maybe it was the same for both T rex and G ochoai so that their arms just got smaller and smaller. (Credit: 9news)

So maybe the animals from the past weren’t that different from those of today, they faced the same challenges and came up with pretty much the same solutions.

Physicists continue to study Neutrinos, the ghost elementary particle, hoping it will lead them to Physics beyond the Standard Model. The KATRIN experiment has now given us our best estimate for the maximum mass of a neutrino.      

The Standard Model of particle physics has several problems. For one thing it simply doesn’t contain gravity in any way. Another problem is the masses of all the particles. For example the muon resembles an electron in every respect except its mass, which is 206.84 times that of its cousin. The standard model can’t simply doesn’t explain that ratio or any of the other mass ratios. In fact the whole concept of generations, particles like the electron, muon and tau that behave in the same fashion except for their mass, is a complete mystery at present. Perhaps the biggest problem with the Standard Model however is that it works so well that we have very few clues pointing toward a more comprehensive theory that will answer our questions.

The Standard Model of Particle Physics tells us so much, but not everything and WE WANT IT ALL!! (Credit: ScienceAlert)

That’s part of the reason why physicists are so busy studying the particle known as the neutrino. These ghost particles have mystified physicists ever since their existence was first predicted by the theoretician Wolfgang Pauli. Pauli proposed the neutrino to explain some discrepancies in the type of radiation known as beta decay.

Wolfgang Pauli was one of the founding fathers of Quantum Mechanics, his exclusion principle is the reason why two objects cannot occupy the same space at the same time! (Credit: Facebook)

Now in beta decay a neutron splits into a proton and an electron. In the process conservation of the electric charge works out, a neutron is neutral while the positive proton and negative electron still add up to zero. The energy of the proton and electron did not always come out the same however, a violation of conservation of energy. And the spins of the particles were just all wrong as well, again violating conservation of angular momentum.

When a neutron decays into a proton the emitted electron is called beta radiation. In order to conserve energy and spin there has to be another particle emitted as well. This is Pauli’s neutrino. (Credit: ww2.ph.ed.ac.uk)

What Pauli proposed was that a third particle, both electrically neutral and with zero rest mass, was emitted at the same time and the experimentalists just hadn’t detected it yet. At first Pauli called his particle the neutron but when the bigger, massive neutron was discovered by James Chadwick, Enrico Fermi then suggested Pauli’s neutral particle be called the neutrino, which is Italian for ‘little neutral one’. Well it took more than twenty years but eventually Pauli’s neutrino was discovered in 1956, and in fact physicists now know that there are three different types of neutrino, one each complimenting the electron, the muon and the tau particles. Again why each generation of electron like particle should have its own neutrino is simply not explained in the Standard Model.

By placing a large detector (r) next to a nuclear reactor Cowan and Reines (l) succeeded in discovering the elusive neutrino. (Credit: CERN Indico)

Now neutrinos interact very rarely with other particles, it’s estimated that a neutrino could fly through a light-year of solid lead and still have a 50-50 chance of coming out the other side. At the same time neutrinos are generated in large amounts in nuclear reactions, such as the fusion reaction that powers our own Sun and the other stars. Solar physicists therefore wanted to try to capture as many solar neutrinos as they could hoping to learn about the interior of the Sun from them.

The Fusion reactions that power the Sun release a lot of neutrinos. If detected here on Earth they can tell us much about what’s going on inside the center of our star. (Credit: Forbes)

Instead they learned more about neutrinos. The first neutrino telescope was built deep beneath the Earth’s surface at the Homestake Mine in South Dakota in order to eliminate contamination from cosmic rays. What the telescope found was that the number of neutrinos coming from the Sun was exactly one-third the expected number. After wondering for some time if something was wrong with their theories of solar fusion, or maybe something was actually wrong with the Sun the physicists eventually found that the three types of neutrino oscillate, that is they change from one type to another over time. The neutrinos generated in the Sun are all electron neutrinos but by the time they reach Earth two-thirds have changed to muon or tau neutrinos.

The idea is crazy and the math is really hard. Could that be why physicists are so interested in neutrino oscillations? (Credit: www-he.scphys.kyoto-u.ac.jp)

Which means that neutrinos must have a rest mass because particles with zero rest mass move at the speed of light and according to Einstein’s theory of relativity time does not pass for anything moving at the speed of light. So the questions now are, just what is the mass of a neutrino and can we learn a clue from that about the masses of all the particles.

According to Relativity the time interval between two events differs for two observers moving relative to each other. For a particle moving at the speed of light time actually stands still! (Credit: Pinterest)

That’s the purpose of the KATRIN experiment at Karlsruhe Institute of Technology in Germany. KATRIN is trying to measure the mass of a neutrino by making the most precise measurements ever of beta decay, the original interaction for which Pauli first proposed the neutrino. Think about it, if the energy of a neutron gets shared in varying amounts between a proton, electron and a neutrino the minimum amount of energy the neutrino can get is its rest mass. So if you measure thousands or better still millions of neutron decays the maximum energy of the proton and electron taken together and subtracted from that of the neutron, is the rest mass of the neutrino. Easier said than done, remember we’re talking about sub-atomic particles here and previous experiments have already concluded that the neutrino rest mass is less than 1/100,000th that of the electron.

The Katrin experiment seeks to measure the mass of a neutrino by measuring the maximum energy that the electron emitted in beta decay can have. The rest has to be the neutrino’s mass. (Credit: DW)

Let me take a moment here to mention the units by which particle physicists measure mass. Remembering Einstein’s most famous equation E=Mc2 physicists like to turn that equation around to get m=E/c2. So to describe the mass of elementary particles physicists use a measure of energy known as the electron-volt, the energy an electron will gain by accelerating across one volt of electrical potential, and divide it by c2 getting eV/c2 or kilo eV/c2 (Kev/c2) or Million eV/c2 (Mev/c2) or even GeV/c2, a billion eV.

Particle physicists measure energy in terms of the ‘electron-volt’, the energy an electron would gain by accelerating across one volt of electric potential. (Credit: Slideshare)

Now neutrons are themselves hard to handle, being neutral you can’t use an electric field to control them. So the KATRIN experiment uses the heavy isotope of hydrogen called Tritium, whose nuclei consists of one proton and two neutrons. Tritium is a well studied beta decay source and as a gas it is much easier to handle than a free neutron would be. Also the proton that results when the neutron decays remains in the nucleus, transforming it to a nucleus of helium-3. That means that the only thing you really have to measure is the energy of the produced electron.

The KATRIN detector being wheeled through the streets of Karlsruhe Germany. The size of the detector gives you some idea just how difficult experiments in particle physics can be to perform. (Credit: Symmetry Magazine)

Nevertheless it’s still a difficult task, which is why the KATRIN experiment is an enormous instrument 70m in length, much of which is the main spectrometer for measuring the electron’s energy. For the experiment the tritium gas of cooled down to a temperature of 30K (-247ºC) in order to minimize thermal motion and an set of 24 superconducting magnets are used to collimate the emitted electrons into the spectrometer.

While KATRIN is still continuing to collect data an analysis of the measurements gathered by the end of 2019 has achieved a milestone, at the 90% confidence level the rest mass of a neutrino is less than 0.8 eV/c2. An elementary particle with a rest mass that is less than 1eV would have been a shocking result just a few decades ago and in a sense a rest mass of around one-millionth that of the electron, or even less, only deepens the mystery of elementary particle masses.

The KATRIN team announcing their latest results, that neutrinos have a mass that is less than 1 electron volt! (Credit: CEA/Irfu)

Still the results of KATRIN are reality and the only way to get beyond the standard model is to gather more facts that don’t fit in the model. Who knows, maybe right now some grad student in some university somewhere is reading the article published in Nature Physics by the KATRIN collaboration and is thinking to themselves, ‘hey, wait a minute… that actually makes sense’! After all, that’s how it started with Pauli, and Einstein, and Bohr and all those others who built the standard model.

Russia’s Invasion of Ukraine is showing all of the signs of turning into a Guerrilla War, and just what is a Guerrilla War?       

In the early morning hours of the 24th of February military forces of the Russian Federation at the orders of their President Vladimir Putin began a full scale assault on the neighboring country of Ukraine. The Russians had taken their time in organizing the attack. More than a month of preparation went into assembling a force of nearly 200,000 men with more than 1,000 tanks along with 2,000 aircraft. Such was the armored firepower of the Russian army that it was widely expected to sweep the much smaller Ukrainian military aside and occupy the capital Kiev along with the county’s other major cities within days.

The Russians even used the nation of Belarus as a staging area for their forces allowing them to attack Ukraine from three sides at once. (Credit: Sky News)

It hasn’t worked out that way. As I write this post we are twelve days into the Ukraine war and Russian forces are bogged down around on several fronts. The Russian units attacking Kiev are facing stiff resistance and have made no progress for the past week while most other major cities are also still in the hands of the Ukrainian government. Russian President Vladimir Putin has unquestionably overestimated his own strength, underestimated the resolve of the Ukrainian people to resist him while at the same time ignoring the determination of the international community to punish him and Russia for his blatant act of aggression.

The Russians succeeded in taking a small amount of Ukrainian territory in the first few days but since then Ukrainian resistance has slowed their advance to a crawl. (Credit: The Washington Post)

Now I do not mean to imply that a Ukrainian victory is coming any time soon. Russian still has enormous forces to bring to bear in this fight and unless Putin is willing to run back home with his tail between his legs this conflict is going to continue and become much more brutal and bloody. There are already signs that the Russians are shifting from a war of decisive battle, i.e. a quick sharp fight with winner takes all, to a war of attrition where the bigger combatant trades casualty for casualty and simply wears down his foe, the most brutal kind of warfare. There are also reports of ever growing numbers of attacks against civilians increasing the casualty figures still higher.

A Sixty Kilometre long Convoy of Russian military vehicles is stalled just north of the Ukrainian capital of Kiev, unable to move for days now. (Credit: CNBC)
Just as in any war, unable to defeat the Ukrainian military the Russians have turned to attacking Civilians. (Credit: The Los Angeles Times)

The problem with that is that the longer the war goes on the likelier it is to devolve into a Guerrilla War so that, even after the organized Ukrainian Army is defeated the Ukrainian people continue to fight on in small bands. Such wars, also known as insurgencies, are quite common and although both lengthy and bloody, they often succeed.

To most Americans Guerrilla War means Vietnam and the fight against the Viet Cong. (Credit: History of Yesterday)

The term Guerrilla, which means little warrior in French, comes from Napoleon’s invasion of Spain in 1808 where a large, well trained and well supplied French army defeated several smaller Spanish armies, marched straight to the Spanish capital, seizing it and installing Napoleon’s brother Joseph as the new Spanish king. Problem was that most of the Spanish people didn’t accept their defeat and soon peasant farmers were taking potshots at French soldiers on guard duty, small bands made up of Spanish soldiers who never surrendered along with ordinary citizens were attacking French supply wagons. With a year the entire countryside of Spain was a battlefield and with the British smuggling in military supplies and eventually troops to aid the guerrillas by 1814 the French were defeated in what Napoleon referred to as his ‘Spanish Ulcer’.

The type specimen for a Guerrilla War however is Napoleon’s invasion of Spain in 1808. The fierceness of that conflict is best depicted in Francisco de Goya’s famous painting El tres de Mayo! (Credit: Wikimedia Commons)

Since then other big countries have tried to use their powerful military against a presumed weaker opponent only to find themselves bogged down in a guerrilla war. In World War 2 Hitler faced strong partisan resistance in both Yugoslavia and the Soviet Union. Partisans are just another word for guerrillas by the way.

Launching a Blitzkrieg into Yugoslavia Hitler quickly captured the capital Belgrade and other major cities but like Napoleon he would never truly conquer the country. (Credit: Wikipedia)

Famously the United States was defeated in a guerrilla war by the Vietnamese and recently by the Afghans. And it’s important to remember that the Russians, back when they called themselves the USSR, were also defeated by Afghan guerrillas during the 1980s, a war that many historians think helped lead to the collapse of the Soviet Union. A war that Putin should remember well!

In 1979 Russian troops poured into Afghanistan. Ten years later the Taliban insurgency had pushed them back out again! (Credit: E-International Relations)

If the fighting in Ukraine continues there is every chance that it will evolve into just such a guerrilla conflict. For one thing the Russians simply do not have enough troops to completely guard the entire country. The US Army War College estimates that in order to really secure a hostile country an occupier must have one soldier for every 50 citizens of that country. To occupy the Ukraine would therefore require an army of somewhere between 800,000 and one million troops, a force that the Russian Federation simply cannot afford. The Russians may hold all of Ukraine’s major cities but any potential Ukrainian guerrillas will have plenty of inadequately guarded forests and marshes in which they can organize or retreat into whenever needed. 

The Forests and Marshlands of Ukraine are the largest remaining in all of Europe. This rugged terrain has served as a hiding place for Guerrillas since the time of the Scythians back in the Iron Age! (Credit: BBC)

Meanwhile the Ukrainian people are already preparing themselves for a guerrilla war, ordinary citizens are lining up at police stations to receive guns so that they can help fight the Russian invaders. Companies that produced alcoholic beverages are now manufacturing Molotov Cocktails, bottles filled with gasoline to use as primitive grenades. These are other activities are typical of a guerrilla war. Everyday that they succeed in resisting the Russian advance the morale of the Ukrainians grows making them more likely to continue the fight even after organized resistance has ended.

Since the Russians took more than a month to ready their invasion force it gave ordinary Ukrainian citizens time to take some military training. Organizing an insurgency even before you’re invaded is something new! (Credit: The Moscow Times)

On the other hand the Russian morale was rather poor at the very start of the war. For all of his propaganda President Putin never succeeded in convincing the Russian people that Ukraine was any kind of threat to them and while the majority of his people continue to support him there is a considerable minority who simply loath their president. Thousands of Russians have already been arrested for protesting against their nation’s invasion of its neighbor, not a good way to start a war that could go on for years.

A 76 year old Russian woman protesting her country’s invasion of its neighbor. How these two big strong Russian Policemen can look themselves in the mirror after arresting her is beyond my understanding! (Credit: HuffPost UK)

Add to that the damage to the livelihood of ordinary Russians due to the massive sanctions that the international community has placed upon the country and the morale of both Russian troops and the Russian people can only decline still farther. Already the value of the Ruble has dropped by more than a third while imports of critical goods into Russia have simply stopped. The unity that nations and corporations around the world have shown in their effort to make Russia pay for its aggression has been unexpectedly strong even taking China’s determination to pay both sides against each other into account.

Let’s be real, the only country that can benefit from this war in Ukraine is China, and they don’t have to do a thing! (Credit: Nikkei Asia)

The fighting in Ukraine also brings with it a new potential horror. For the first time ever Nuclear Power Plants are on the front lines of the fighting in a major war. On the very first day of their assault Russian forces seized Chernobyl, the site of the world’s worst nuclear accident. Fortunately there was little fighting involved and the containment vessel surrounding the damaged reactor was unharmed. Seven days later Russian units attacked and occupied the Zaporizhzhia Nuclear Plant, the largest nuclear power plant in Europe. This time the Russians appear to have used more force than necessary and a training building caught fire, raising fears that a nuclear accident could occur.

The Russians seized the Chernobyl nuclear site on the first day of the war after a short but fierce fight. The ruined reactor is still safe in its containment building but there’s a war going on around it! Also Ukraine has four other nuclear plants any one of which could become a major disaster if some errant missile should strike it! (Credit: iNews)

Ukraine still has three more nuclear power plants and as the fighting grows more intense the possibility of a real nuclear disaster happening cannot be ignored. And even if the Russians do manage to seize and secure all of Ukraine’s nuclear facilities without incident what about the guerrilla war that is almost certain to follow. Partisan units act independently, that is their great strength, but that also means they sometimes act against the wishes of superiors. What if some leader of a guerrilla band convinces himself that a nuclear disaster would be just the thing to spur the Russians into leaving?

Blowing up large infrastructure to harass the enemy is what guerrillas do. This is the Greek bridge Gorgopotmos which was destroyed bu Greek Partisans during the Nazi occupation of Greece in WW2. (Credit: GreekReporter.com)

All of which means that the fighting over Ukraine has just started, and is likely to get much worse. This war could drag on for years and as far as I can see will only result in terrible harm to both countries that will take decades to repair.

Before turning to Politics Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky actually played the President of his country on a TV show. Now he’s showing world leaders how to inspire a country to win against all odds. (Credit: Los Angeles Times)

What does Putin hope to accomplish with this war anyway. Well, like Napoleon he hopes to install a government that will be subservient to his will. He hopes to make Ukraine a vassal state to Russia as a way to rebuild the old empire of Russia. But the Ukrainian people will have none of that, after centuries of Russian domination they have tasted independence and like it. And the inspiration that the country is finding in their President Volodymyr Zelensky has fired their courage and resolve while impressing the entire world. In the end Russia simply cannot hold Ukraine, indeed most Russians don’t want to. Only one man is responsible for all of this madness and bloodshed. In the end Vladimir Putin will have achieved nothing with his war against Ukraine except to secure his place in history as just a small and rather inferior version of Adolph Hitler.

Space News for March 2022: Plans being Finalized for the End of the International Space Station and what will come Thereafter.      

The International Space Station (ISS) has been the mainstay of manned space flight now for more than twenty years but the venerable space base is currently beginning to show its age. Occasional air leaks are becoming more and more of problem while the power system is in need of constant repair; even the smell of the station is becoming a problem. Think about how your house would smell if you couldn’t open a window for twenty years to let in some fresh air!

According to Astronaut Scott Kelly, who spent more than a year aboard the International Space Station (ISS), the place smells just like a jail. That’s easy to understand after twenty years of human habitation without any thing like real fresh air. (Credit: Daily Mail)

More than that NASA, the American space agency, simply wants out of the business of running a station in Low Earth Orbit, preferring instead to get back to their task of exploring the solar system. Current plans are for NASA to continue to support ISS operations through the year 2030, but like any bureaucratic organization NASA has already started the process of figuring out exactly how to terminate the ISS and what will take its place.

When Skylab fell out of orbit it was an an uncontrolled reentry. Pieces of America’s first space station fell on Australia and although no one was hurt it was a real danger! NASA intends to make certain that the same thing doesn’t happen with the ISS. (Credit: NASA)

As I have mentioned in several previous posts, see posts of 29 December 2021 and 2 October 2021, NASA intends to rent space for its astronauts on future commercial space stations. Indeed the space agency is helping to fund the design phase for such a commercial space station at three aerospace corporations, Blue Origin, Northrop Grumman along with a consortium named Nanoracks that includes Lockheed Martin and Voyager Space. Once one of the designs from these corporations is chosen NASA will help fund the construction of the station, becoming the primary tenant.

Preliminary concept design for Northrup Grumman’s space station. Notice the attached Space X Dragon capsule center below and Northrup’s own unmanned cargo vessel Cygnus right above it. (Credit: Northrup Grumman)

Once that commercial station is up and operating the question then becomes what to do about the ISS, the largest and most massive structure ever placed into orbit. Since the ISS was built in pieces, one module at a time, should it be taken apart and de-orbited piece by piece? Or should it all be brought down in one piece?

Exploded view of the major components of the ISS. Since the station was built in pieces should it be brought down from orbit in pieces or in one big piece? (Credit: European Space Agency)

NASA has decided on the latter scenario with a plan to bring the station into a lower orbit slowly before using a large retro-burn to begin a re-entry designed to finally drop the whole thing into the southern Pacific Ocean. The ISS will meet it demise at a location in the ocean furthest from land called Point Nemo approximately midway between New Zealand and South America. Most of the ISS will probably burn up as it descends through the atmosphere but because it is so large undoubtedly more than a few big pieces will survive so NASA will take care to keep the falling debris as far from human habitations as possible.

Point Nemo is the name that has been given to a position in the south Pacific that is farthest from any inhabited land. (Credit: The Sun)

Now NASA will not be the only tenant in any new space station because the business of space tourism is definitely heating up. Jared Isaacman, the billionaire who funded last year’s first ever totally commercial space mission has now arranged a series of four space missions with Space X beginning with another Dragon capsule mission, perhaps as early as the end of 2022. That first mission in what Isaacman is calling the Polaris Program will last five days and take the Dragon capsule to a much higher orbit while also including the first Extravehicular Activity (EVA) for a commercial space mission.

Having funded the first all tourist space Mission Billionaire Jared Isaacman is now partnering with Space X for a series of manned mission termed the Polaris Project. (Credit: CNBC)

Details of the later three missions are sketchy at present but Isaacman hopes that the final Polaris mission will be the first manned launch of Space X’s massive Starship rocket. Funding for the Polaris Program will come from a combination of Isaacman and Space X itself and the stated goal of the missions is “…to advance long-duration spaceflight capabilities and guiding us toward the ultimate goal of facilitating Mars exploration.” According to Isaacman.

Space X is busy preparing for the first orbital test launch of their Starship rocket. (Credit: San Antonio Express)

There are a few other items of interest that I’d like to cover quickly. The schedule for NASA’s Artemis 1 mission, the first, unmanned launch of the big Space Launch System (SLS) has been pushed back once again. After years of delays and cost overruns the first launch of the SLS had originally been scheduled for late last year, only to be pushed back to the first quarter of this year. Now NASA is admitting that more time is required to complete a long list of safety checks before launch so the Artemis 1 mission is now being tentatively scheduled for sometime in the spring. Another couple of months delay in a program that is years late may seem like just a drop in the bucket but the question remains, will the SLS ever fly?

The first test vehicle of the massive Space Launch System (SLS) has been assembled in the Vehicle assembly Building at Cape Kennedy. Testing however has bee slow and the rocket is now scheduled to roll out to the launch pad before late March 2022. (Credit: Spaceflight Insider)

Mars exploration, at least robotic exploration is proceeding however. The Ingenuity helicopter, which after completing its five ‘test flights’ has since then been working as an airborne scout for the Perseverance rover. For the past several months though dust storms on the Red Planet have kept Ingenuity grounded. At the beginning of February however the skies began to clear and on February the 8th the little aircraft took off once more on a 100 second flight, its 19th flight on Mars. Not bad for a technology demonstration vehicle that was only supposed to fly five times.

It keeps going and going. An artist’s impression of the Ingenuity helicopter with the Perseverance rover in the background. After 19 flights that little aircraft shows no sign of slowing down. (Credit: SciTechDaily)

And speaking of Mars, the Perseverance Rover has been collecting rocks that NASA hopes will one day be transferred to a planned Mars Sample Return Mission, a lander on the Red Planet that will contain a rocket capable of lifting those Mars rocks off of the planet’s surface. That rocket has been given the name of the Mars Ascent Vehicle (MAV) and the current plan is for it to rendezvous in Mars orbit with the European Space Agency’s Earth Return Orbiter (ERO) spacecraft. The ERO will acquire the samples of Martian soil from the MAV and bring them back to Earth.

NASA has awarded a contract to Lockheed Martin for a rocket to take off from the Martian surface with soil samples. The rocket will then rendezvous in Mars orbit with a European spacecraft to bring the sample back to Earth. (Credit: NASA Mars Exploration Program)

Now the contract for the Mars Ascent Vehicle has been awarded to Lockheed Martin for a potential value of $194 million dollars. The contract is slated to run for about six years and Lockheed Martin will provide several test units in addition to the actual flight vehicle. It is hoped that the Mars sample return mission will take place in the late 2020s with the actual return of the samples by 2031.

Basic Outline of the Mars Sample Return Mission. The Perseverance rover is already collecting samples that could be collected by the transfer rover shown above and brought back to Earth. If all goes according to plan we could have pieces of Mars being studied in our labouratories within the next ten years. (Credit: Nature)

Manned and unmanned there’s progress being made in man’s efforts to explore and settle our solar system.

The United States has been neglecting upgrades to its Infrastructure for decades. Now, as our Bridges, Roads and Water Systems crumble around us we’re still just trying to put a patch on the problem.

Any country is only so strong as the infrastructure that binds it together. A nation’s roads, power grid, airports, water and gas distribution systems are the way that goods and people move from one location to another. They are the public services that a nation’s citizens use everyday. The economy of a country, any country is a function of the size and efficiency of that country’s infrastructure. Simply put, without infrastructure the people cannot obtain the goods and services they need or desire.

Infrastructure is the natural Environment of a Civilization, the Ecology of Society. But unlike a natural Ecology it has to be Maintained by the people who make up that Society. (Credit: Market Business News)

Like anything else in this world a nation’s infrastructure needs to be maintained, upgraded and hopefully expanded in order for that nation to grow. The task of caring for a nation’s infrastructure primarily rests with its government, and any government that fails to maintain that infrastructure in good condition has simply failed to do their job of governing.

Would you feel safe Driving on a Highway held up by these pillars. Chances are that you do so on a regular basis! (Credit: REMI)

Back on the 28th of January the Fern Hollow Bridge, located some 15 km east of downtown Pittsburgh here in Pennsylvania collapsed without warning shortly before the morning rush hour. The bridge, which carries an estimated 14,500 vehicles daily fortunately only had four vehicles on it at the time of its collapse and none of the people in those vehicles suffered more than minor injuries. The bridge, which was built in 1970, had been rated as being in ‘poor condition’ since 2011 and its last inspection in 2019 found that both the bridge’s superstructure and deck were in need of repair. Such a dilapidated state for a bridge in our country is no accident; rather it is a disgrace.

The Fern Hollow Bridge just east of Pittsburgh. Fortunately no one was seriously hurt in this collapse, but it is just another reminder of the deteriorating state of our Nation’s Infrastructure. (Credit: 90.5 WESA)

The story of the Fern hollow bridge got a bit of extra attention in the media because, by shear coincidence President Biden was scheduled to travel to Pittsburgh that very day to talk about the passage of his trillion dollar infrastructure bill, of which $27 billion has been allocated over the next five years for the repair of bridges. The President went on with his visit, indeed he made the collapse of the bridge a focal point of his talk about how vital it is for our country to get to work on maintaining and repairing the nation’s infrastructure.

On his visit to Pittsburgh to promote his Infrastructure bill President Biden used the Fern Hollow Bridge as an example of how Government needs to do more to maintain critical roads, bridges and other facilities. (Credit: Politico)

So why did the Fern Hollow Bridge spend 10 years in ‘poor condition’ without being repaired before finally just collapsing from neglect, and why should a President be touting his success in getting a bill passed that allocates money for what is actually one of government’s prime obligations? Well that’s because for decades now the American people and their government have simply ignored the important public works around them, preferring to adopt the strategy of, if it breaks fix it, otherwise who cares.

Fixing things costs money and for infrastructure that means raising taxes and to our modern politicians that means nothing gets fixed! (Credit: Constructiondorks.com)

This state of affairs is spelled out in detail in a report examining infrastructure in the US from 1929 to 2019 by Ray C. Fair of Yale University’s Department of Economics. In his report Mr. Fair analyzes spending on both civilian infrastructure and defense infrastructure whereas I shall concern myself only with civilian infrastructure. Mr. Fair also combines the contributions of State and Local governments with that of the Federal government and I shall follow him in that respect.

Reaching a peak in the 1960s, Government spending on Infrastructure has declined dramatically since then, reaching a new low in 2018. (Credit: S&P Global)

What the report clearly shows is a steady decline in government spending on infrastructure beginning during the 1970s and continuing until the present day. In other words, over the last 40-50 years, even as our roads, bridges, water and sewer systems etc. have grown older and in greater need of maintenance and replacement the United States, at all levels of government has spent less and less on their upkeep. This decline is evident in the graphs shown above and below.

Breaking the spending on Infrastructure down into Roads, Sewers and Water Systems it is obvious that all sectors are seeing a serious decline in funding. (Credit: Ray C. Fair, Yale University)

As a part of his analysis Mr. Fair also investigated spending on infrastructure for a number of other countries and discovered that several western nations, including the United Kingdom, Germany and to a lesser extent France showed similar declines beginning slightly later in the 1980s.

Other countries, like Germany and the UK have also experienced a sharp decline in Infrastructure spending. (Credit: Ray C. Fair, Yale University)

What makes this situation even harder to understand is that, throughout the period of reduced spending on infrastructure the US government has been setting records for deficit spending, that is the Federal Government is spending more money than it takes in through taxes. So, if our governments aren’t spending money on infrastructure what are they spending it on?

Year by year our Nation’s debt divided by GDP just keeps on growing. If you or I tried to spend this much more than we take in we’d be Bankrupt within months! (Credit: Visual Capitalist)

Well, first of all since 1980 the Federal government has passed three big tax cuts in a strategy once called ‘Reaganomics’ but which has now proven itself to be more like the voodoo economics that it was once criticized as. With each tax cut the deficit rose considerably and in order to reduce the deficit somewhat corners were cut elsewhere, with infrastructure being an obvious choice since few people pay much attention to it.

Reagan’s tax cuts were supposed to grow our Economy so that they would end up paying for themselves. Didn’t quite work out that way and the Bush and Trump tax cuts failed to grow anything except the deficit. (Credit: CNN Business)

At the same time we wanted more entitlements, more Social Security benefits, more Medicare and now Obamacare. We wanted a big social safety net without having to pay for it putting more pressure on those parts of the federal budget few people care about, like infrastructure. After all the infrastructure we have now is good enough for now, so why spend any money on it.

With the continued growth of Entitlements, here called Mandatory Programs, spending for other needs, here called Discretionary spending, is growing smaller and smaller. Infrastructure has taken arguably the biggest hit from this scenario. (Credit: Mercatus Center)

It’s simply another symptom of our society’s loss of faith in, even interest in the future. Rather than allocating funds to make certain that our country can continue to function decades in the future we want low taxes and government benefits now, and let our children and grandchildren pay for it.

It’s one thing to do this as Individuals but when Society does this as a whole it’s going to make things really bad for the next Generation. (Credit: Amazon.com)

Now Biden’s trillion dollar infrastructure package is obviously a step in the right direction. However it is certainly much too small and what’s really needed is not a one time package, however large but a strong commitment to long term investment in infrastructure.

How it usually works in Washington! (Credit: Cleveland.com)

And that will certainly require raising taxes, something that our current fractious government is probably incapable of doing. So we can all look forward to more bridges collapsing, more water mains bursting, more power outages and just an ever increasing breakdown of the public services we depend on everyday.